Sunday’s episode of Carte Blanche featured an expose about a former El-Al security official’s shocking allegations of race profiling, degrading interrogations, and operating illegally under the nose of South African authorities at OR Tambo international.
Jonathan Garb went to Carte Blanche with these allegations after being dismissed from El-Al presumably for leading a protest for higher pay and better medical benefits.
Although most allegations were about racial profiling, considerable time was devoted to Virginia Tilley’s interrogation by El-Al in South Africa on her way to Israel. Tilley is a white woman who is one of the foremost anti-Israel lobbyists in South Africa. Had Carte Blanche done some research they would have found nothing at all sinister about a country interrogating someone who is leading the calls for the destruction of said state.
The Star reported on the story yesterday, claiming that Garb is leading a trio of former employees claiming that their former employer is a front for Israeli spooks.
The Star reports that Acsa’s Solomon Makgale said El Al had security threats because of the Middle East conflict but that the allegations were of concern.
If you missed the show, our friends at the Media Review Network (who are still pushing the blood libel that Israelis kidnap Palestinians to steal their kidneys) have the entire transcript, so you can find it there.
As for the response from El-Al, you can find it here: El-Al responds to Carte Blanche Allegations
El-Al Response
Last night’s Carte Blanche insert on the El Al airline showed the public only too clearly the dangers faced by the Israeli airline from terrorists and fundamentalists determined to attack innocent passengers irrespective of their ages, colours and creeds, and blow them into oblivion.
The security regulations enforced by El Al to ensure the safety of all its passengers, which is the first and most vital aspect of any passenger airline, are of the highest standard, and were attested to by the complainant himself who said that had El Al security been active at the time of the World Trade Centre attacks in New York in 2001, there would have been no 9/11.
Because of the nature of the threats made against the airline, El Al unapologetically questions and challenges any suspicious person or passenger. That is the airline’s right, and is similarly carried out by airlines all around the world. The accusation of racial profiling, however, is completely without justification: Virginia Tilley is white, and an outspoken enemy of Israel. In addition, among all the tens of thousands of people of different colours and religions who travel safely and regularly to Israel, the statements of two men cannot be taken as testament to a policy which in fact does not exist.
No-one who travels to the USA can deny that the security into and out of that country, and the checks at the various airports, are thorough and unpleasant but are necessary in these days of increased and unrestricted acts of terror and murder. While South Africa has to date remained fairly immune from such acts, no-one can afford to be complacent; and the fact that EL Al makes every effort to protect the lives of the passengers should be highly commended rather than condemned. |
Update at 2009/09/03
A comment from the Blacklisted Dictator highlights the special need for El-Al security at foreign airports:
L.A. AIRPORT GUNMAN IDENTIFIED AS EGYPTIAN IMMIGRANT
The FBI identified the gunman who shot and killed two people in the Los Angeles International Airport yesterday as Hesham Mohamed Hadayet, a 41-year-old Egyptian who came to the United States ten years ago.
On the Fourth of July holiday, Hadayet opened fire at the LAX ticket counter of the Israeli national airline El Al, killing two and wounding several others. He was subsequently shot and killed by an El Al security guard. According to the FBI, the gunman used a .45-caliber handgun in the shooting, and was also armed with a 9-mm pistol and a six-inch hunting knife.
In the shootout, Hadayet killed 25-year-old El Al employee Victoria Hen and 46-year-old Jacob Aminov, who was waiting at the ticket counter. A 61-year-old Canadian woman was shot in the ankle and a male victim was treated for injuries received from being pistol-whipped. The El Al security guard who finally shot Hadayet was also treated for a knife-wound. |
Update at 2009/09/03
The SA Jewish Report has reported today that since the labour lawsuit has taken a political twist, Michael Bagraim has recused himself from the case.
Comments Disclaimer